A Scientific Ranking of Halloween Candy by an Unqualified 87-Year-Old
I have no scientific background whatsoever, but I have been personally field-testing Halloween candy since roughly 1948, which I consider a more relevant credential than most letters after somebody’s name. Here is my ranking, conducted under rigorous conditions, meaning I sat on my porch and ate the research.
1st Place — The Full-Size Candy Bar
Still the undisputed jackpot. A house that hands these out is a house that understands the assignment. I remember exactly which houses did this in 1955, and I remember them fondly.
2nd Place — Anything Peanut Butter
Reliable, well-regarded, does not require a translator to explain what it is. A serious contender that has never once let anybody down.
3rd Place — The Fun-Size Version of Something Good
Not as good as full-size, obviously, but you can eat four of them and tell yourself it’s really just one, which is the kind of math a man my age has earned the right to do.
Last Place — The Wax-Paper Peanut Butter Kiss
Present in every pillowcase since the dawn of the holiday. Wanted by no one. I am convinced there is a single, enormous underground supply that just keeps circulating between houses, unopened, forever.
Disqualified — The Apple
A well-meaning but fundamentally incorrect submission. This is a candy holiday. I don’t care how organic it is. Disqualified, appeal denied.
That’s my ranking, filed under “peer-reviewed by exactly one peer.” Feel free to argue with me in the comments. I read every single one, and I promise you, I’ve got opinions on this that go back further than most of your family trees.
— H.D.



